JM Smucker Company (SJM)

The liquidity ratios of JM Smucker Company over the period presented exhibit notable variations and emerging patterns across different timeframes up to October 2024.

Current Ratio Analysis:
The current ratio demonstrates significant fluctuations, beginning at 0.96 in July 2020 and decreasing to a low of 0.68 by April 2021, indicating periods where the company's short-term assets slightly lagged behind its short-term liabilities. Subsequently, the ratio exhibits a recovery trend, reaching 1.44 in April 2023, reflecting improved liquidity and a more comfortable buffer to cover short-term obligations. Notably, there is an extraordinary spike to 3.20 in October 2023, suggesting a temporary enhancement in short-term assets relative to liabilities, possibly from strategic asset management or asset accumulation. However, this increase is followed by a decline to approximately 0.52–0.58 during the subsequent quarters, indicating a reduction in liquidity cushion and potential challenges in short-term asset management. The latest readings for January through April 2025 remain below 1, signaling a pattern of liquidity constraints or a conservative asset structure.

Quick Ratio Analysis:
The quick ratio mirrors some of the fluctuations observed in the current ratio but generally indicates a more conservative view of liquidity excluding inventory. It starts at 0.43 in July 2020, largely declining to an even lower 0.27 by July 2021, which reflects limited availability of liquid assets to meet immediate liabilities. There is an oscillation around the 0.3 to 0.4 range until April 2023, where the ratio sharply increases to 0.88, highlighting a period of enhanced liquidity and liquidity management. The most striking change occurs in October 2023, when the quick ratio surges to 2.53, signaling a significant increase in liquid assets available to cover short-term liabilities—possibly due to asset sales or improved cash management. Subsequently, the ratio declines sharply to around 0.21–0.26 through early 2025, indicating reduced liquidity levels and a move back toward more conservative asset holdings.

Cash Ratio Analysis:
The cash ratio, representing the most conservative measure of liquidity, remains relatively low throughout the period, reflecting limited cash holdings in relation to current liabilities. It generally stays below 0.2, with initial figures around 0.19 in July 2020 declining to as low as 0.01 by October 2022. The ratio notably spikes in April 2023 at 0.58, aligning with the peak observed in the quick ratio, suggesting a temporary accumulation of cash or highly liquid assets. However, this spike is short-lived, and from July 2023 onward, the ratio reverts to very low levels, mostly below 0.03. The extremely low or near-zero cash ratios in recent quarters imply that the company relies less on cash holdings and more on other liquid assets or credit facilities to manage its short-term obligations.

Overall Assessment:
The company's liquidity position shows variability with periods of strengthening and weakening. The pronounced peaks in October 2023 in the current, quick, and cash ratios suggest strategic liquidity management or extraordinary circumstances. However, the subsequent decline in these ratios indicates ongoing challenges in maintaining consistent liquidity levels, reflecting either operational, financial, or structural adjustments. The persistent below-unity current and quick ratios during most periods suggest that liquidity remains a concern, emphasizing the importance of operational efficiency and effective working capital management.

---

Additional liquidity measure

The analysis of JM Smucker Company's cash conversion cycle (CCC) over the specified periods reveals notable fluctuations and trends. The CCC measures the duration, in days, it takes for the company to convert its investments in inventory and other resources into cash flows from sales, encompassing days sales outstanding (DSO), days inventory outstanding (DIO), and days payable outstanding (DPO).

From July 31, 2020, to April 30, 2021, there was a consistent decline in the CCC, dropping from 38.64 days to 18.77 days. This suggests improved operational efficiency and faster cash turnaround during this period. The cycle experienced a slight increase later in 2021, reaching approximately 35.48 days by October 31, 2021, before decreasing again to a low of 16.78 days on April 30, 2022, indicating further operational enhancements.

Subsequently, the CCC showed variability: it increased to about 32.30 days in July 2022, then slightly declined to 33.65 days by October 2022. Early 2023 marked a reduction, with the cycle falling to 24.08 days by January 2023. Notably, a significant sharp decrease occurred in April 2023, with the CCC reaching just 1.18 days, highlighting an exceptionally streamlined cash conversion process during that quarter.

Following this trough, the cycle increased again to 11.92 days in July 2023 and slightly rose to 14.72 days by October 2023. The trend continued with modest fluctuations into early 2024, with values around 16.55 days in January and 11.44 days in April. The cycle rose again in July and October 2024 to approximately 24.16 and 23.18 days, respectively. The most recent data point for January 2025 indicates a cycle of 23.95 days, with April 2025 showing a decrease to 20.47 days.

Overall, the trend demonstrates periods of significant improvement, notably in April 2023, possibly reflecting operational optimizations, supply chain efficiencies, or changes in receivables and payables management. Conversely, the increases at other times suggest periods of operational or external challenges impacting working capital management. The fluctuations indicate the company's ongoing efforts to balance inventory, receivables, and payables to optimize cash flow and remain flexible in changing market conditions.