Worthington Steel Inc (WS)

Return on sales

The analysis of Worthington Steel Inc.'s profitability ratios over the period from February 2023 to May 2025 reveals a trend of gradual improvement in profitability metrics, followed by some fluctuations toward the latter part of the period.

The gross profit margin showed a consistent upward trajectory, increasing from 7.91% as of February 28, 2023, to a peak of approximately 13.67% by February 29, 2024. This indicates that the company has been able to enhance its efficiency in managing production costs relative to sales, leading to higher gross profitability. After reaching this peak, the gross margin experienced slight fluctuations, settling at around 12.56% by May 31, 2025. Such stability suggests maintained or slightly improved control over direct costs amid varying sales levels.

Operating profit margin also demonstrated a positive trend during the first half of the period, rising from 2.77% in February 2023 to about 6.77% in February 2024. This indicates effective management of operating expenses that contributed to higher operating profitability. However, the margins declined modestly thereafter, dropping to approximately 4.60% by February 2025, which may suggest increased operating costs or competitive pressures impacting profit efficiency.

The pretax margin mirrored this pattern, increasing from 1.98% in February 2023 to a peak of 6.83% in February 2024, before decreasing to around 4.68% by February 2025. This correlation signifies that the variations in operational efficiency and cost control are reflected at the pretax level as well.

Net profit margin followed a similar upward trend, improving from 1.31% in February 2023 to approximately 4.88% in February 2024, indicating better bottom-line profitability. Subsequent fluctuations resulted in a marginal decrease to approximately 3.41% by February 2025, suggesting that net profitability has been somewhat impacted by factors such as increased expenses, interest, taxes, or other financial costs.

Overall, Worthington Steel Inc. demonstrated noteworthy improvements in gross, operating, pretax, and net profit margins during the first part of the analyzed timeframe, highlighting enhancements in cost management and operational efficiency. Nonetheless, the later periods reveal some challenges in maintaining those gains, with margins slightly receding but remaining above initial levels, thereby indicating a period of stabilization following prior growth.

---

Return on investment

The provided data reflects Worthington Steel Inc.'s profitability ratios over multiple periods, revealing trends and variations in the company's ability to generate earnings relative to its assets, capital, and equity.

Operating Return on Assets (Operating ROA):
From February 2023 to May 2024, the Operating ROA exhibits a consistent upward trajectory, increasing from 5.96% to a peak of 10.38%. This indicates an improving efficiency in generating operating income from the company's assets during this period. However, post-May 2024, the ratio demonstrates some volatility, declining slightly to 9.25% in August 2024 before rebounding to 11.33% in November 2024. In the subsequent periods, there appears to be a decline, with the ratio decreasing to 8.11% in February 2025 and further to 7.49% by May 2025. Overall, the trend illustrates a period of growth followed by fluctuations and a softening in operating profitability at the later stages.

Return on Assets (ROA):
The ROA trend aligns somewhat with Operating ROA but is generally lower, reflecting the impact of non-operating factors such as interest income or expenses. It rises from 2.82% in February 2023 to a peak of 6.47% in November 2023, then reaches 9.00% in February 2024, indicating improved overall asset utilization and profitability. Thereafter, a downward adjustment occurs, and by May 2025, the ROA declines to 5.64%. The overall pattern suggests initial improvement in asset efficiency, followed by a decline in the subsequent periods.

Return on Total Capital:
This ratio demonstrates a pronounced upward trend from 7.67% in February 2023 to a peak of 25.07% in February 2024, signaling significant enhancement in the company's ability to generate returns from both debt and equity financing. After reaching this high point, the ratio declines steadily, falling to 20.81% in May 2024, then dropping further to 14.27% by February 2025, and sharply to 7.36% in May 2025. These fluctuations may indicate shifting capital efficiency, potential changes in leverage, or operational challenges affecting overall capital productivity.

Return on Equity (ROE):
ROE exhibits a steady increase from 4.84% in February 2023 to 17.75% in February 2024, reflecting improved profitability attributable to shareholder investment. Post-February 2024, the ratio shows signs of moderation, decreasing to 15.74% in May 2024 and further to 12.35% in August 2024. The trend continues downward, reaching 14.19% in November 2024 and eventually decreasing to 10.69% in February 2025 and 10.31% in May 2025. The pattern indicates initial strong performance that diminishes over time, possibly due to increased equity base, margin pressures, or other factors impacting net income relative to shareholders’ equity.

Summary:
Overall, Worthington Steel Inc. experienced an initial period of strengthening profitability across most ratios, particularly noticeable in Operating ROA and ROA, peaking around late 2023 and early 2024. Subsequently, there has been observed deterioration in these ratios, especially from early 2024 onward, suggesting potential challenges in sustaining profitability, operational efficiency, or capital management. The sharp decline in Return on Total Capital and ROE in the later periods underscores shifts in leverage or profit margins, warranting further analysis into operational strategies, cost management, and capital structure adjustments during this timeframe.